Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Are the points reliable?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Are the points reliable?

    I am rebuilding 2 1979 850 g both are low mileage with points, condensers. Are the points reliable? Is it better to change to electronic? What are some of the better electronic ignitions? Last ones I used were Boyer from the UK.
    Thanks
    joepenoso

    2X 1979 GS Suzuki G

    #2
    Points were used successfully for 3/4 of a century in countless vehicles. The only real drawback is they require regular maintenance.
    Ed

    To measure is to know.

    Mikuni O-ring Kits For Sale...https://www.thegsresources.com/_foru...ts#post1703182

    Top Newbie Mistakes thread...http://www.thegsresources.com/_forum...d.php?t=171846

    Carb rebuild tutorial...https://gsarchive.bwringer.com/mtsac...d_Tutorial.pdf

    KZ750E Rebuild Thread...http://www.thegsresources.com/_forum...0-Resurrection

    Comment


      #3
      I run several points setups on my bikes, some others i use the Dyna S.

      Points i check once or twice a year, unless they are worn they function perfectly for ages without maintenance.
      + : cheaper than the Dyna S
      - : require a little bit of maintenance.

      Dyna S :

      + : set it and forget it.
      my bikes seem to start just a tiny bit easier with the Dyna S and
      run a little smoother but hardly a difference.
      - : approx 150$, needs an extra power wire spliced into the cabling,
      very sturdy but pickups fail sometimes (very rarely). Not to repair when underway while
      points can be replaced or adjusted.
      Last edited by Rijko; 08-12-2020, 12:23 PM.
      Rijk

      Top 10 Newbie Mistakes thread

      CV Carb rebuild tutorial
      VM Carb rebuild tutorial
      Bikecliff's website
      The Stator Papers

      "The thing about freedom - it's never free"

      Comment


        #4
        OEM points and condensers are expensive. Cheap ones may not be that great. I still have cars and motorcycles with points. Put an electronic ignition on my Cortina, because the distributor is under the side drafts. It got an intermittent fault where it would misfire after an hour or so. I had a hard time diagnosing it. That particular electronic ignition is bad about not liking to sit with the key on while the motor isn't running. I think the Dyna in the GS1000G I have here may hae taken a dump. The bike runs, but can't take throttle under load after the first 2 or so minutes of use. The farther you go, the less load it can handle. It fires on all cylinders. I'm not certain its a Dyna, but the coils are. This bike has given no trouble in the years I have owned it. A little over 60K. I put a clutch in it, a starter, and 3 sets of tires. Needs another set of tires.
        sigpic Too old, too many bikes, too many cars, too many things

        Comment


          #5
          As Ed said, regular maintenance.
          In addition to timing you have to watch the maximum opening or dwell time to allow energy to build up.
          The mechanical advance gets forgotten.
          Unless you have high end diagnostic gear the only way to test condensers is by replacement
          Reduction of performance can be slow and you don't notice until you work on them and the throttle response is crisper.
          Availability of quality parts is an issue. If you see a spring rusting get it out of there before it breaks.
          Three thousand miles is probably the limit for a four with new points.
          Compared with electronic systems they are often called dinosaur technology but they work and fixing them is easy.
          That said there is a Piranha fitted to my bike from who knows when. Don't know if they are even made anymore. Seems bulletproof.
          97 R1100R
          Previous
          80 GS850G, 79 Z400B, 85 R100RT, 80 Z650D, 76 CB200

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by 850 Combat View Post
            OEM points and condensers are expensive.
            OEM points are on Ebay now for approx. 15$, condensers the same : that's 60$ per bike.
            But they can be found way cheaper, my local motorshop was happy to unload their last 10 sets
            of point sets and condensers on me for 10$ per bike.
            "Nobody buys those anymore" they said.
            The cheapest Dyna DS3-2 is 133$.
            That's 1230$ i just saved, the way i look at it.

            If i had just 1 bike, i'd mount a Dyna S. But having over 20 ... i'm real happy to ride with easy to maintain, low maintenance point sets.
            They last a very long time and are very reliable.

            If i rode tens of thousands of kilometers per bike i might wear out the contact breakers but
            doing a couple of thousand per year per bike i think they will outlast me.
            Rijk

            Top 10 Newbie Mistakes thread

            CV Carb rebuild tutorial
            VM Carb rebuild tutorial
            Bikecliff's website
            The Stator Papers

            "The thing about freedom - it's never free"

            Comment


              #7
              I wonder if a kickstart works as well with electronic ignition?

              Points generally disappeared when kick starts did. ( or did BMWs carry on with both..?)

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Gorminrider View Post
                I wonder if a kickstart works as well with electronic ignition?

                Points generally disappeared when kick starts did. ( or did BMWs carry on with both..?)
                If there's a healthy battery to provide power to the ignition, wether you crank the engine using a kickstarter or using the starter motor does not make much of a difference.
                If the battery is low, a kickstarter is an advantage when the battery will not properly crank the engine.

                For the big GS-es, the starter motor proved very reliable.
                That's why for instance the choice could be made to scrap the kickstarter for the GS1000 to save weight.

                If you have a bike without a battery, the initial power to the ignition system must be provided in a different way : by kicking the kickstarter the rotor is cranked to do just that.
                They switched to electronic ignition (Hall sensor pickups in stead of contact points) for most bikes.
                I worked on a modern Husqvarna offroad recently which has no battery but relies on coils to provide power to the Hall sensors and CDI.
                Rijk

                Top 10 Newbie Mistakes thread

                CV Carb rebuild tutorial
                VM Carb rebuild tutorial
                Bikecliff's website
                The Stator Papers

                "The thing about freedom - it's never free"

                Comment


                  #9
                  but Particular to the Suzuki GS, I'm thinking of the speed a kickstarter can spin the engine...The "ignitor" (TCI) relies on a pulse created by the spin of the crank. Will there be enough signal?
                  IE: if you pass a magnet s l o w l y past a coil, it may not produce the signal the TCI wants. But points open instantly.

                  Of course, I can spin my GS400 plenty quick, if it had a kickstart. But my 650? mmm dunno.

                  add: I'd stick with the points. as well said above, they work well. If you go on a trip and your electronic ignition fails, you will have to camp at a mailbox. But points and condensor in the bottom of a saddlebag are trivial.
                  Last edited by Gorminrider; 06-06-2021, 11:33 AM.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Gorminrider View Post
                    but Particular to the Suzuki GS, I'm thinking of the speed a kickstarter can spin the engine...The "ignitor" (TCI) relies on a pulse created by the spin of the crank. Will there be enough signal?
                    IE: if you pass a magnet s l o w l y past a coil, it may not produce the signal the TCI wants. But points open instantly.

                    Of course, I can spin my GS400 plenty quick, if it had a kickstart. But my 650? mmm dunno.

                    add: I'd stick with the points. as well said above, they work well. If you go on a trip and your electronic ignition fails, you will have to camp at a mailbox. But points and condensor in the bottom of a saddlebag are trivial.
                    Particular to the Suzuki GS : that's why i differentiated between setup with battery or not.
                    The GS bikes i worked on before all had a battery, i do not know of a GS without one.
                    But i do not pretend to know all GS models, maybe there were some without a battery.
                    Rijk

                    Top 10 Newbie Mistakes thread

                    CV Carb rebuild tutorial
                    VM Carb rebuild tutorial
                    Bikecliff's website
                    The Stator Papers

                    "The thing about freedom - it's never free"

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Gorminrider View Post
                      but Particular to the Suzuki GS, I'm thinking of the speed a kickstarter can spin the engine...The "ignitor" (TCI) relies on a pulse created by the spin of the crank. Will there be enough signal?
                      IE: if you pass a magnet s l o w l y past a coil, it may not produce the signal the TCI wants. But points open instantly.

                      Of course, I can spin my GS400 plenty quick, if it had a kickstart. But my 650? mmm dunno.

                      add: I'd stick with the points. as well said above, they work well. If you go on a trip and your electronic ignition fails, you will have to camp at a mailbox. But points and condensor in the bottom of a saddlebag are trivial.

                      I used to have a 79 GS 750 E. I bought it with points installed in it. a couple years later, I installed a Dyna ignition in it and it kick started just fine. BTW, electronic ignitions (DYNA) are NOT CDI.
                      All the robots copy robots.

                      Komorebi-The light filtering through the trees.

                      You are free to choose, but you are not free from the consequences of your choices.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        @Earlfor OK! thanks!
                        I understand your Dyna is compatible-with/similar-to the Suzuki system and therefore it follows that WERE a person to fit a kickstarter to a non-equipped, stock Suzuki with an original TCI system, and a working battery, it should/could work...

                        @ Rijko
                        You make a good point with cost, weight, and consumer convenience. Likely that is it, but the coincidence of losing the kick and gaining the TCI is notable. So, just as discussion to clarify my original question:
                        If you have a bike without a battery, the initial power to the ignition system must be provided in a different way : by kicking the kickstarter the rotor is cranked to do just that.
                        They switched to electronic ignition (Hall sensor pickups in stead of contact points) for most bikes.
                        I worked on a modern Husqvarna offroad recently which has no battery but relies on coils to provide power to the Hall sensors and CDI.
                        As you know, Suzukis don't have Hall sensors. (solid state devices) My point was twards them having wee signal generators whose magnets spin in a small diameter versus say, (a bike I'm familiar with),a Honda *, and its CDI system where the trigger pulse comes from the quite big and wide flywheel magnet. That is, the Honda's magnet travels faster. I'm likely barking up an empty tree but:

                        While the (Honda )CDI system is entirely independent of the battery*, the Suzuki is not. Is it possible to kickstart a Suzuki with a truly dead battery,with points or without ? If there's a long hill, rolling down it could work, but spinning the alternator with a kickstart fast enough to generate all the voltage and current required seems difficult compared to a CDI or Magneto...

                        *a CDI being an improvement on the magneto and higher voltages are involved
                        Last edited by Gorminrider; 06-06-2021, 05:15 PM.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Brendan W View Post
                          That said there is a Piranha fitted to my bike from who knows when. Don't know if they are even made anymore. Seems bulletproof.
                          Still available...
                          Lumenition, Micro Dynamics Newtronic product information application lists faq guides installation instructions


                          I picked up a spare ignitor box several years ago just in case, and never needed it.
                          ---- Dave
                          79 GS850N - Might be a trike soon.
                          80 GS850T Single HIF38 S.U. SH775, Tow bar, Pantera II. Gnarly workhorse & daily driver.
                          79 XS650SE - Pragmatic Ratter - goes better than a manky old twin should.
                          92 XJ900F - Fairly Stock, for now.

                          Only a dog knows why a motorcyclist sticks his head out of a car window

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Gorminrider View Post
                            I wonder if a kickstart works as well with electronic ignition?
                            Definitely. My 79 was fitted with the Piranha system and kick-started excellently.
                            ---- Dave
                            79 GS850N - Might be a trike soon.
                            80 GS850T Single HIF38 S.U. SH775, Tow bar, Pantera II. Gnarly workhorse & daily driver.
                            79 XS650SE - Pragmatic Ratter - goes better than a manky old twin should.
                            92 XJ900F - Fairly Stock, for now.

                            Only a dog knows why a motorcyclist sticks his head out of a car window

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Get the Dyna S and get it over with.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X