would you replace a stator with these readings?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • don_gibb6512

    #1

    would you replace a stator with these readings?

    Stator test:

    Red lead of MM to output wire/ Black lead to output wire @ 5K rpm = 64v across all three wires

    Ohm reading across all 3 pairs = .4 ohm

    Ohm reading across 2 wires to engine casing = .4 ohm
    Ohm reading across 1 wire to engine casing = .3 ohm

    Looked, can't see anywhere that the wires from the stator are crimped, bad, nothing.

    Don
  • tkent02
    Forum LongTimer
    Past Site Supporter
    • Jan 2006
    • 35571
    • Near South Park

    #2
    Originally posted by don_gibb6512
    Stator test:

    Red lead of MM to output wire/ Black lead to output wire @ 5K rpm = 64v across all three wires
    So it is making voltage...



    Originally posted by don_gibb6512
    Ohm reading across 2 wires to engine casing = .4 ohm
    So it's pretty much shorted to ground, it can't make any voltage at all.

    Your readings conflict with each other, are you using an autoranging multimeter incorrectly?
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v5...tatesMap-1.jpg

    Life is too short to ride an L.

    Comment

    • bonanzadave
      Forum Guru
      Past Site Supporter
      • Jul 2006
      • 9622
      • Minnesota

      #3
      Nope. 64V AC right ? Why do you ask ? Charging issues ? What is the DC charging voltage at the battery at or above 2k RPMs ?
      82 1100 EZ (red)

      "You co-opting words of KV only thickens the scent of your BS. A thief and a putter-on of airs most foul. " JEEPRUSTY

      Comment

      • posplayr
        Forum LongTimer
        GSResource Superstar
        Past Site Supporter
        • Dec 2007
        • 23673
        • Tucson Az

        #4
        Originally posted by tkent02
        So it is making voltage...




        So it's pretty much shorted to ground, it can't make any voltage at all.

        Your readings conflict with each other, are you using an autoranging multimeter incorrectly?
        There is another thread with the OP is doing exactly the same thing. They should take a video to see what they are doing wrong.

        Comment

        • don_gibb6512

          #5
          The video is a good idea. The DC V output at the battery was 12.8v at 5k rpms. The RR had a burnt spade connector to ground and the tests on it were indicative of a failed RR. Because of the readings I got was why I asked about the stator in the first place. I don't understand it either. It would seem that there is some kind of failure in the wiring to ground on the stator that would cause the Ohm readings to be the way they are but I'll be damned if I can find it.

          EDIT NOTE: I apologize on my typo. This should have been 12.08v @ 5k rpms, not the original post of 12.8v.

          It's an Electrosport stator, if that means anything.

          Yes, it was 64v AC across the stator wires.

          I'm using a Radio Shack 23 range LCD Digital Multimeter and to the best of my knowledge, I'm using it correctly.

          I ran these tests 3 times to be sure I was consistent on the readings.

          Thanks Would you replace this stator?

          Don
          Last edited by Guest; 10-19-2010, 04:23 AM.

          Comment

          • bonanzadave
            Forum Guru
            Past Site Supporter
            • Jul 2006
            • 9622
            • Minnesota

            #6
            Originally posted by don_gibb6512
            The RR had a burnt spade connector to ground and the tests on it were indicative of a failed RR.

            Thanks Would you replace this stator?

            Don
            No. I would cut out those RR connectors. Replace them with some quality splices and try it again. Run a dedicated ground wire from the RR right to the - battery. If that dont work I would send a PM to Duane for a new RR.
            Last edited by bonanzadave; 10-17-2010, 07:22 PM.
            82 1100 EZ (red)

            "You co-opting words of KV only thickens the scent of your BS. A thief and a putter-on of airs most foul. " JEEPRUSTY

            Comment

            • posplayr
              Forum LongTimer
              GSResource Superstar
              Past Site Supporter
              • Dec 2007
              • 23673
              • Tucson Az

              #7
              Originally posted by don_gibb6512
              The video is a good idea. The DC V output at the battery was 12.8v at 5k rpms. The RR had a burnt spade connector to ground and the tests on it were indicative of a failed RR. Because of the readings I got was why I asked about the stator in the first place. I don't understand it either. It would seem that there is some kind of failure in the wiring to ground on the stator that would cause the Ohm readings to be the way they are but I'll be damned if I can find it.

              It's an Electrosport stator, if that means anything.

              Yes, it was 64v AC across the stator wires.

              I'm using a Radio Shack 23 range LCD Digital Multimeter and to the best of my knowledge, I'm using it correctly.

              I ran these tests 3 times to be sure I was consistent on the readings.

              Thanks Would you replace this stator?

              Don
              U are measuring resistance between the legs to ground when the stator wires are open right?

              12.8 at 5K RPM is doing something.

              Could you please do a Quick Test?

              Want to just get a feel for how the charging is working? Do a Quick_Test

              Comment

              • don_gibb6512

                #8
                Sending Duane the $ for a new RR tomorrow. I'm redoing ALL connectors in this circuit. What bites is that I did that the LAST time. Bought a Klein crimper, used dielectric grease and soldered the connections that didn't HAVE to be removed to do testing. Used new wire, new connectors, tried to do everything right and yet this still happened. ARGH!!! The Stator papers say that the ohm readings across the pairs on the stator should be .5-2v but mine was .4 and the ohm reading from the wires to ground are bad if it reads anything between 0-100 ohm. Since mine are .4 and mostly .4 on the wire to ground, I assumed that the stator was bad. Is this not the case? What does that say about the Stator paper results then? I'm confused.

                Don

                Going to bed. Gonna shoot pool tomorrow night and do something that I'm actually good at. Cheers.
                Last edited by Guest; 10-17-2010, 07:33 PM.

                Comment

                • posplayr
                  Forum LongTimer
                  GSResource Superstar
                  Past Site Supporter
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 23673
                  • Tucson Az

                  #9
                  Originally posted by don_gibb6512
                  Sending Duane the $ for a new RR tomorrow. I'm redoing ALL connectors in this circuit. What bites is that I did that the LAST time. Bought a Klein crimper, used dielectric grease and soldered the connections that didn't HAVE to be removed to do testing. Used new wire, new connectors, tried to do everything right and yet this still happened. ARGH!!! The Stator papers say that the ohm readings across the pairs on the stator should be .5-2v but mine was .4 and the ohm reading from the wires to ground are bad if it reads anything between 0-100 ohm. Since mine are .4 and mostly .4 on the wire to ground, I assumed that the stator was bad. Is this not the case? What does that say about the Stator paper results then? I'm confused.

                  Don

                  Going to bed. Gonna shoot pool tomorrow night and do something that I'm actually good at. Cheers.
                  There are two methods of wiring a stator Delta and Y.

                  I'll say this maybe there is an issue.

                  If your stator is wired in a Y configuration it is possible for it to be grounded and still produce power. That is because the center of the Y is considered a neutral and even though it is generally left floating, maybe it is being grounded as part of the way the stator is wound.

                  The GS1100E manual shows a Y configuration.

                  Maybe that part of the test should be removed as now I'm not certain if it allways applies especially in a Y configuration.

                  Comment

                  • Graham

                    #10
                    Originally posted by don_gibb6512
                    Stator test:

                    Red lead of MM to output wire/ Black lead to output wire @ 5K rpm = 64v across all three wires

                    Don

                    If you read any voltage (while running and unplugged) from stator wires to ground (casing) buy a new stator.

                    Comment

                    • posplayr
                      Forum LongTimer
                      GSResource Superstar
                      Past Site Supporter
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 23673
                      • Tucson Az

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Graham
                      If you read any voltage (while running and unplugged) from stator wires to ground (casing) buy a new stator.
                      sorry his reading are fine; check the manual if you don't believe me.

                      Comment

                      • Graham

                        #12
                        Originally posted by posplayr
                        sorry his reading are fine; check the manual if you don't believe me.
                        Just check factory manual and the readings below are not in there. This is a ground in the stator halfway thru one coil. Should be tested while running to conform. If he doesn’t want to do a running test, don’t.
                        Ohm reading across 2 wires to engine casing = .4 ohm
                        Ohm reading across 1 wire to engine casing = .3 ohm

                        Comment

                        • posplayr
                          Forum LongTimer
                          GSResource Superstar
                          Past Site Supporter
                          • Dec 2007
                          • 23673
                          • Tucson Az

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Graham
                          Just check factory manual and the readings below are not in there. This is a ground in the stator halfway thru one coil. Should be tested while running to conform. If he doesn?t want to do a running test, don?t.
                          Ohm reading across 2 wires to engine casing = .4 ohm
                          Ohm reading across 1 wire to engine casing = .3 ohm

                          >>>>If you read any voltage (while running and unplugged) from stator wires to ground (casing) buy a new stator.


                          I'm taking about this statement you made above. Yes the issue of stator shorts to ground is being discussed and I raised the possibility that it is Y configuration stators.

                          Comment

                          • Graham

                            #14
                            Originally posted by posplayr
                            >>>>If you read any voltage (while running and unplugged) from stator wires to ground (casing) buy a new stator.


                            I'm taking about this statement you made above. Yes the issue of stator shorts to ground is being discussed and I raised the possibility that it is Y configuration stators.
                            It is a Y (wye) configuration. And it will put out AC power from wire to wire if not plugged in to the regulator. My point is a ohmmeter isn?t the best way to check windings, ohmmeter could read metal filled oily residue or moister. Voltmeter won?t lie on a running test. I?m done.

                            Comment

                            • posplayr
                              Forum LongTimer
                              GSResource Superstar
                              Past Site Supporter
                              • Dec 2007
                              • 23673
                              • Tucson Az

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Graham
                              It is a Y (wye) configuration. And it will put out AC power from wire to wire if not plugged in to the regulator. My point is a ohmmeter isn?t the best way to check windings, ohmmeter could read metal filled oily residue or moister. Voltmeter won?t lie on a running test. I?m done.
                              I agree, trying to measure 0.5 ohms with $10 ohm meters and dirty connections is none to good. Also it is hard to mistake 60-80 VAC.

                              Comment

                              Working...