Confirmation of diagnosis on GS1100E charging system

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • dweller
    Forum Mentor
    • Jul 2015
    • 108
    • SW Oregon

    #1

    Confirmation of diagnosis on GS1100E charging system

    I have a no charge condition on my recently acquired '82 GS1100EZ (brand new battery, full charge, reads 12.7 at rest and 11.7 with bike running at any engine speed). I've done a ton of reading (stator papers, forum, bikecliff, etc.) and have just completed testing. The OEM connector to the OEM R/R was completely melted and wires fried. I wasn't too concerned about checking the R/R because I intend to install a series unit, most likely the Compufire. I did all the stator tests and I believe it is fried. Resistance between the three outputs with the bike off are all between 5 and 12 ohms. Resistance between each of the three outputs and the engine casing are all 0L. Output with bike running at 5000rpm from each is 70-71 volts. At 5000rpm, voltage from each output is at 35 volts testing through the battery ground terminal. If I read the fault finding chart correctly, this last test is the sure indicator that the stator is fried.

    Am I correct? Thanks for the help.
    1982 GS1100EZ, second owner, 11,000 miles
    2000 XR650R, plated
  • bonanzadave
    Forum Guru
    Past Site Supporter
    Super Site Supporter
    • Jul 2006
    • 9624
    • Minnesota

    #2
    Originally posted by dweller
    Output with bike running at 5000rpm from each is 70-71 volts.
    That seems OK. Get the new RR and wire it straight in with some good butt splices and a proper crimper. Ground it straight to the - batt terminal.
    82 1100 EZ (red)

    "You co-opting words of KV only thickens the scent of your BS. A thief and a putter-on of airs most foul. " JEEPRUSTY

    Comment

    • glib
      Forum Sage
      Past Site Supporter
      • Jul 2014
      • 1175
      • Stockton, CA

      #3
      Originally posted by dweller
      Output with bike running at 5000rpm from each is 70-71 volts. At 5000rpm, voltage from each output is at 35 volts testing through the battery ground terminal. If I read the fault finding chart correctly, this last test is the sure indicator that the stator is fried.

      Am I correct? Thanks for the help.
      Stator is toast.

      I have installed two Electrosport stators and two Compufire R/Rs on my two 1100's. No more charging fears. Electrosport ESG024. Shop around. I got mine for about $85. Compufire 55402 best price at Amazon $153.

      Edit: I would not know the first thing about this if posplayr had not patiently taken me through the same process. My numbers were similar but not as uniform.
      Last edited by glib; 07-28-2017, 09:40 PM.
      sigpic
      1983 GS1100ES (Bought July 2014)
      1983 GS1100E (Bought July 2014)
      1985 GS700ES (Bought June 2015) Sold
      On Christ the Solid Rock I Stand
      All Other Ground is Sinking Sand

      Comment

      • dweller
        Forum Mentor
        • Jul 2015
        • 108
        • SW Oregon

        #4
        Thanks guys
        1982 GS1100EZ, second owner, 11,000 miles
        2000 XR650R, plated

        Comment

        • JTGS850GL
          Forum Guru
          Past Site Supporter
          • Aug 2013
          • 9735
          • GA

          #5
          I'd go with an SH775 regulator. The Compufires are over priced. You can pick up a good used SH775 for around $40. They almost never fail so buying used is not an issue.
          http://img633.imageshack.us/img633/811/douMvs.jpg
          1980 GS1000GT (Daily rider with a 1983 1100G engine)
          1998 Honda ST1100 (Daily long distance rider)
          1982 GS850GLZ (Daily rider when the weather is crap)

          Darn, with so many daily riders it's hard to decide which one to jump on next.;)

          JTGS850GL aka Julius

          GS Resource Greetings

          Comment

          • posplayr
            Forum LongTimer
            GSResource Superstar
            Past Site Supporter
            • Dec 2007
            • 23673
            • Tucson Az

            #6
            Originally posted by JTGS850GL
            I'd go with an SH775 regulator. The Compufires are over priced. You can pick up a good used SH775 for around $40. They almost never fail so buying used is not an issue.
            It depends on how much room you have. On the GS1100E there in not a whole lot; with minor modification teh CF can fit in the stock location. There is a small performance difference but it is size difference that is the overwhelming factor.

            Comment

            • dweller
              Forum Mentor
              • Jul 2015
              • 108
              • SW Oregon

              #7
              The size difference was the main reason why I was thinking Compufire. That and it seems to run cooler according to what I've read...
              1982 GS1100EZ, second owner, 11,000 miles
              2000 XR650R, plated

              Comment

              • glib
                Forum Sage
                Past Site Supporter
                • Jul 2014
                • 1175
                • Stockton, CA

                #8
                Tight but it fits.

                IMG_0298.jpg
                sigpic
                1983 GS1100ES (Bought July 2014)
                1983 GS1100E (Bought July 2014)
                1985 GS700ES (Bought June 2015) Sold
                On Christ the Solid Rock I Stand
                All Other Ground is Sinking Sand

                Comment

                • dweller
                  Forum Mentor
                  • Jul 2015
                  • 108
                  • SW Oregon

                  #9
                  One last question guys. I've modified my electrical plate to accept the new Compufire R/R. New Electrosport stator is installed. I'm following advice from previous work by various members on wiring and grounding. Since I'm wiring the three stator wires straight to the Compufire, what is the consensus on what size fuse to use in the OEM fuse block for the main power circuit now that the current path is altered? Thanks
                  1982 GS1100EZ, second owner, 11,000 miles
                  2000 XR650R, plated

                  Comment

                  • posplayr
                    Forum LongTimer
                    GSResource Superstar
                    Past Site Supporter
                    • Dec 2007
                    • 23673
                    • Tucson Az

                    #10
                    Originally posted by dweller
                    One last question guys. I've modified my electrical plate to accept the new Compufire R/R. New Electrosport stator is installed. I'm following advice from previous work by various members on wiring and grounding. Since I'm wiring the three stator wires straight to the Compufire, what is the consensus on what size fuse to use in the OEM fuse block for the main power circuit now that the current path is altered? Thanks
                    Fuse size has nothing to do with the stator connections.

                    Comment

                    • Who Dat?
                      Forum Mentor
                      • Jun 2012
                      • 461
                      • On the edge.

                      #11
                      The only "alteration" that you have done is to bypass a useless loop of one stator output wire that goes to a connector under the tank and loops back down to the R/R. Wiring the three stator output wires directly to the R/R input wires eliminates all the potential corrosion points in all those connectors along the way.

                      Hopefully you have wired the red output wire from the R/R back to the red wire in the stock location on the bike. If you did that, there is no need to change any fuses.
                      If you're not living on the edge, you're taking up too much space.

                      Comment

                      • posplayr
                        Forum LongTimer
                        GSResource Superstar
                        Past Site Supporter
                        • Dec 2007
                        • 23673
                        • Tucson Az

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Who Dat?
                        The only "alteration" that you have done is to bypass a useless loop of one stator output wire that goes to a connector under the tank and loops back down to the R/R. Wiring the three stator output wires directly to the R/R input wires eliminates all the potential corrosion points in all those connectors along the way.

                        Hopefully you have wired the red output wire from the R/R back to the red wire in the stock location on the bike. If you did that, there is no need to change any fuses.
                        +1 ...............

                        Comment

                        • dweller
                          Forum Mentor
                          • Jul 2015
                          • 108
                          • SW Oregon

                          #13
                          Yes, after I though about it last night I realized there is only a need to change fuse size if I wired the R/R output directly to the battery. Thanks for confirming this. And for the help and advice!
                          Last edited by dweller; 08-26-2017, 12:22 PM.
                          1982 GS1100EZ, second owner, 11,000 miles
                          2000 XR650R, plated

                          Comment

                          • posplayr
                            Forum LongTimer
                            GSResource Superstar
                            Past Site Supporter
                            • Dec 2007
                            • 23673
                            • Tucson Az

                            #14
                            Originally posted by dweller
                            Yes, after I though about it last night I realized there is only a need to change fuse size if I wired the R/R output directly to the battery. Thanks for confirming this. And for the help and advice!
                            +2...............

                            Comment

                            Working...