Cranking compersion figures

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • posplayr
    Forum LongTimer
    GSResource Superstar
    Past Site Supporter
    • Dec 2007
    • 23673
    • Tucson Az

    #16
    Hey, there are some great pics in that last link. Here is a picture of where i my girl freind at the time took me for my birthday party (25th) . Can't say exactly what the prize was; but you might be able to imagine. She was a Jazzercize teacher.

    See pics of the seven falls; we were also doing some compression testing


    Comment

    • 49er
      Forum Sage
      Past Site Supporter
      • Jul 2006
      • 1517
      • Napier, New Zealand

      #17
      Originally posted by chef1366
      I don't think that's enough carbon buildup to cause that much jump in compression numbers. Are you sure your guage is any good?
      My thoughts too.

      That little formula 9.5 -1 = 175 psi, so 10.25-1 = 190 psi isn't what happens in real life rebuilds. Too many variables happen that affect cylinder filling.

      I read that link and found that those compressions ranged from 180 -205 psi on the first test and on a cold engine. When it warmed up, you would probably have seen another 20 psi.

      Just notice your last post but haven't opened it yet. Are you sure that it wasn't your blood pressure that high on that day??
      :) The road to hell is paved with good intentions......................................

      GS 850GN JE 894 10.5-1 pistons, Barnett Clutch, C-W 4-1, B-B MPD Ignition, Progressive suspension, Sport Demons. Sold
      GS 850GT JE 1023 11-1 pistons. Sold
      GS1150ES3 stock, V&H 4-1. Sold
      GS1100GD, future resto project. Sold

      http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000001.jpg
      http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000581.jpg

      Comment

      • posplayr
        Forum LongTimer
        GSResource Superstar
        Past Site Supporter
        • Dec 2007
        • 23673
        • Tucson Az

        #18
        Originally posted by 49er
        My thoughts too.

        That little formula 9.5 -1 = 175 psi, so 10.25-1 = 190 psi isn't what happens in real life rebuilds. Too many variables happen that affect cylinder filling.

        I read that link and found that those compressions ranged from 180 -205 psi on the first test and on a cold engine. When it warmed up, you would probably have seen another 20 psi.

        Just notice your last post but haven't opened it yet. Are you sure that it wasn't your blood pressure that high on that day??
        Will do a quick check yet again on my compressor tonite; however to reiterate the same gauge (which was purchased new 1.5 years ago) and I think I may have even double checked with my old gauge measured:

        145-165 psi on a well running GS750EX
        135-145 psi (if I recall ) on the banana motor Bill has in bike now.
        and was as high as 205 psi on my old stock motor.

        I would guess the same gauge might come in at 180'ish psi on my 1166?

        Comment

        • 49er
          Forum Sage
          Past Site Supporter
          • Jul 2006
          • 1517
          • Napier, New Zealand

          #19
          Originally posted by posplayr
          Will do a quick check yet again on my compressor tonite; however to reiterate the same gauge (which was purchased new 1.5 years ago) and I think I may have even double checked with my old gauge measured:

          145-165 psi on a well running GS750EX
          135-145 psi (if I recall ) on the banana motor Bill has in bike now.
          and was as high as 205 psi on my old stock motor.

          I would guess the same gauge might come in at 180'ish psi on my 1166?
          Don't be disappointed if it's not that high (180). IMO, the greater cam duration and valve overlap, coupled with the increased cross section area through the 4 valves (compared to 2 valves) will hurt the cranking compression figures. But, were you able to check both compression figures at 5000 rpm, the 4 valve engine would be well ahead.
          :) The road to hell is paved with good intentions......................................

          GS 850GN JE 894 10.5-1 pistons, Barnett Clutch, C-W 4-1, B-B MPD Ignition, Progressive suspension, Sport Demons. Sold
          GS 850GT JE 1023 11-1 pistons. Sold
          GS1150ES3 stock, V&H 4-1. Sold
          GS1100GD, future resto project. Sold

          http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000001.jpg
          http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000581.jpg

          Comment

          • posplayr
            Forum LongTimer
            GSResource Superstar
            Past Site Supporter
            • Dec 2007
            • 23673
            • Tucson Az

            #20
            OK Check out the compresor with 5 seperate guages on it. Turns out there is anout 10-15 PSI variance in the cheap Harbor freight guages, but the two compression testes are within 5 PSI at 90 psi (the limit on my compressor).

            The Purple cased guage is the one I used.

            Here is the same pic of the banna bike after I had bought it.

            Comment

            • posplayr
              Forum LongTimer
              GSResource Superstar
              Past Site Supporter
              • Dec 2007
              • 23673
              • Tucson Az

              #21
              Here is the reading from Bills Banana off of two different cylinders. Reads 210 psi. This was stone cold and not run in probably 3-5 years.

              Well I check the original head from the ED and it was stock with the same height as another ESD head I have.

              If anything this guage shown is reading low compared to the other three on the compressor and it is the same as the other compression tester guage. Is is hard to believe it has a 50% scale factor error by the time it reaches 210 psi indicated .

              Anybody got a phone number so I call NIST.

              The way I do the test is to repeatably crank till the psi hit a max with the throttle open while injecting starter fluid with a lit match







              Gottch no starter fluid.
              Last edited by posplayr; 10-24-2009, 01:01 AM.

              Comment

              • 49er
                Forum Sage
                Past Site Supporter
                • Jul 2006
                • 1517
                • Napier, New Zealand

                #22
                Originally posted by posplayr
                Here is the reading from Bills Banana off of two different cylinders. Reads 210 psi. This was stone cold and not run in probably 3-5 years.

                Well I check the original head from the ED and it was stock with the same height as another ESD head I have.

                If anything this guage shown is reading low compared to the other three on the compressor and it is the same as the other compression tester guage. Is is hard to believe it has a 50% scale factor error by the time it reaches 210 psi indicated .

                Anybody got a phone number so I call NIST.

                The way I do the test is to repeatably crank till the psi hit a max with the throttle open while injecting starter fluid with a lit match







                Gottch no starter fluid.
                When did you do this test on Bill's Banana motor? He told me a couple of days ago that it was a good runner, but definitely not stock. Doesn't sound like an engine that hasn't run for 3-5 years to me.
                :) The road to hell is paved with good intentions......................................

                GS 850GN JE 894 10.5-1 pistons, Barnett Clutch, C-W 4-1, B-B MPD Ignition, Progressive suspension, Sport Demons. Sold
                GS 850GT JE 1023 11-1 pistons. Sold
                GS1150ES3 stock, V&H 4-1. Sold
                GS1100GD, future resto project. Sold

                http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000001.jpg
                http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000581.jpg

                Comment

                • Guest

                  #23
                  I'll check the compression today to end the speculation.

                  Comment

                  • 49er
                    Forum Sage
                    Past Site Supporter
                    • Jul 2006
                    • 1517
                    • Napier, New Zealand

                    #24
                    Originally posted by chef1366
                    I'll check the compression today to end the speculation.
                    Hey Bill, it's not necessary. By the way, who owns the Banana, posplayr or you?
                    :) The road to hell is paved with good intentions......................................

                    GS 850GN JE 894 10.5-1 pistons, Barnett Clutch, C-W 4-1, B-B MPD Ignition, Progressive suspension, Sport Demons. Sold
                    GS 850GT JE 1023 11-1 pistons. Sold
                    GS1150ES3 stock, V&H 4-1. Sold
                    GS1100GD, future resto project. Sold

                    http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000001.jpg
                    http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000581.jpg

                    Comment

                    • Guest

                      #25
                      Originally posted by 49er
                      Hey Bill, it's not necessary. By the way, who owns the Banana, posplayr or you?
                      I own it but he bought it for me and stored it at his house for awhile. Now it's at Kris V's house getting ready to race.

                      Comment

                      • posplayr
                        Forum LongTimer
                        GSResource Superstar
                        Past Site Supporter
                        • Dec 2007
                        • 23673
                        • Tucson Az

                        #26
                        Originally posted by chef1366
                        I'll check the compression today to end the speculation.
                        Bill unless u plan to remove the rockers, u will not b able 2 reproduce the compression test

                        Comment

                        • 49er
                          Forum Sage
                          Past Site Supporter
                          • Jul 2006
                          • 1517
                          • Napier, New Zealand

                          #27
                          Originally posted by posplayr
                          Bill unless u plan to remove the rockers, u will not b able 2 reproduce the compression test
                          Ha Ha, nice to see amongst all the Bull Sh!t, there's still time for a sense of humour.
                          :) The road to hell is paved with good intentions......................................

                          GS 850GN JE 894 10.5-1 pistons, Barnett Clutch, C-W 4-1, B-B MPD Ignition, Progressive suspension, Sport Demons. Sold
                          GS 850GT JE 1023 11-1 pistons. Sold
                          GS1150ES3 stock, V&H 4-1. Sold
                          GS1100GD, future resto project. Sold

                          http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000001.jpg
                          http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s...s/P1000581.jpg

                          Comment

                          Working...