Layman's Course in Mech Eng: Stiffness 101

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • posplayr
    Forum LongTimer
    GSResource Superstar
    Past Site Supporter
    • Dec 2007
    • 23673
    • Tucson Az

    #1

    Layman's Course in Mech Eng: Stiffness 101



    There seems to be a pretty prevalent lack of understanding of basic structures and specifically what makes things stiff. The link above does a pretty good job of explaining it. While engineers typically use CAD programs to numerically compute structural loads and stresses; you don't need to spend 4-5 years getting an ME degree to understand the following . In fact the little explanation below will probably be very enlightening to alot of Laymen.

    As an introduction to the link, I will explain it even more simply. With these concepts maybe the presentation will make more sense.

    First a beam in structures is anything that has a length with a uniform cross section. So a section of pipe, an I beam member, board, a piece of plywood are all beams under this definition.

    If you mount one end of the beam solidly to the wall (your choice of how), and then simply push down on the end at the other side of the beam, you will start to "bend" the beam. This is called a "Cantilever" beam

    The amount the beam bends (or angular rotation) per unit force (or moment) is called stiffness.

    To understand what effects stiffness you have to realize what is going on inside the beam along the entire length of the beam. If pushing down on this beam, the entire top of the beam is in being stretched. The entire lower surface of the beam is being compressed. Since for the moment we will assume symmetrical beams, the amount of compression force and elongation forces are equal and opposite mirror images of each other with there being no forces on the beam along the center line (about the moment).

    Also it is an interesting principle that the forces are highest at the furtherest distance from this zero centerline. In fact because the forces are highest further away from the centerline, the stiffness is highest when there is alot of material away from the centerline. This is why an I beam has two horizontal flanges that are separated by a vertical member. It is the spacing of the flanges that really makes the I beam stiff. It doesn't matter much how thick the separating plate is.

    With this in mind, look at the graph below. It compares 4 different beam sections to compare them for relative stiffness. The load is assumed to be in the vertical plane (just like my example). The steeper the slope the stiffer. The box is the stiffness by 30%-40%. The rectangle laying on it's side is way weaker than the rest. So (given a type of material), for stiffness what matters is how much material is located at the furtherest distance from the parting line of the compression and elongation forces in the beam.

    Hope this helps for any would be swing arm fabers

    Pos
    Last edited by posplayr; 04-25-2009, 03:27 PM.
  • pntrdave

    #2
    There seems to be a pretty prevalent lack of understanding of basic structures and specifically what makes things stiff.
    Sure glad that is not the only explanation of what makes things stiff.

    Comment

    • Suzuki_Don

      #3
      Originally posted by pntrdave
      Sure glad that is not the only explanation of what makes things stiff.
      Please explain. Come on put it into words. C'mon.

      Comment

      • Zooks

        #4

        Comment

        • ryonker

          #5
          Just two words;

          VIVA VIAGRA

          Comment

          • rapidray
            Forum Guru
            GSResource Superstar
            • Oct 2006
            • 8195
            • So Cal

            #6
            My wife is good at stiff! Ray.

            Comment

            • tkent02
              Forum LongTimer
              Past Site Supporter
              • Jan 2006
              • 35571
              • Near South Park

              #7
              Originally posted by rapidray
              My wife is good and stiff! Ray.
              Did Mike do that?
              http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v5...tatesMap-1.jpg

              Life is too short to ride an L.

              Comment

              • shadowfist

                #8
                what makes things stiff relies greatly on a very overlooked factor in this thread so far...

                AGE OF THE METERIAL

                the 'fresher' the material the greater variety of circumstances that stiffness will occur.
                this only applies to a certian amount of freshness, on a graph you would notice that stiffness occurs greatly in the 14-16 year range and then slowly tapers from that point. with virtually no stiffness present in younger material.

                Comment

                • posplayr
                  Forum LongTimer
                  GSResource Superstar
                  Past Site Supporter
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 23673
                  • Tucson Az

                  #9
                  on a graph you would notice that stiffness occurs greatly in the 14-16 year range and then slowly tapers from that point. with virtually no stiffness present in younger material.
                  do you have a graph?

                  Comment

                  • pntrdave

                    #10
                    I'm sorry I hijacked your thread. I thought your original post was very informative.

                    From the picture Zooks posted looks like he has the weekend party pack. Hmmmm.... wonder when they are going to start selling the viagra/condom combo pack?

                    Comment

                    • Hammered

                      #11
                      Thats a good read posplayr. Ill be copying a bit of that to add to what Ive learned.

                      Comment

                      • Guest

                        #12
                        Originally posted by pntrdave
                        I'm sorry I hijacked your thread. I thought your original post was very informative.

                        From the picture Zooks posted looks like he has the weekend party pack. Hmmmm.... wonder when they are going to start selling the viagra/condom combo pack?
                        Aren't most guys on Viagra shooting blanks anyway?

                        Comment

                        • shadowfist

                          #13
                          Originally posted by posplayr
                          do you have a graph?
                          why yes, yes i do.

                          Comment

                          • posplayr
                            Forum LongTimer
                            GSResource Superstar
                            Past Site Supporter
                            • Dec 2007
                            • 23673
                            • Tucson Az

                            #14
                            Wow I did not realize the ISC has done so much research .

                            I was hoping there would be another spike after 50

                            That chart is a little dated of course 2006; there might be some hope yet

                            Comment

                            • tkent02
                              Forum LongTimer
                              Past Site Supporter
                              • Jan 2006
                              • 35571
                              • Near South Park

                              #15
                              Originally posted by chef1366
                              Aren't most guys on Viagra shooting blanks anyway?
                              Originally posted by shadowfist
                              why yes, yes i do.
                              This one just HAD to be fixed.
                              http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v5...tatesMap-1.jpg

                              Life is too short to ride an L.

                              Comment

                              Working...