Received the replacement from OldVet (thank you again) today. I'm working a swing shift tomorrow to do some network testing so I'll try to knock it out early in the day.
-
Required reading for all forum users!!!
Welcome!
Register to access the full functionality of the GSResources forum. Until you register and activate your account you will not have full forum access, nor will you be able to post or reply to messages.A note to new registrants...
All new forum registrations must be activated via email before you have full access to the forum.A Special Note about Email accounts!
DO NOT SIGN UP USING hotmail, outlook, gmx, sbcglobal, att, bellsouth or email.com. They delete our forum signup emails.A note to old forum members...
I receive numerous requests from people who can no longer log in because their accounts were deleted. As mentioned in the forum FAQ, user accounts are deleted if you haven't logged in for the past 6 months. If you can't log in, then create a new forum account. If you don't get an error message, then check your email account for an activation message. If you get a message stating that the email address is already in use, then your account still exists so follow the instructions in the forum FAQ for resetting your password.Have you forgotten your password or have a new email address? Then read the forum FAQ for details on how to reset it.
Any email requests for "can't log in anymore" problems or "lost my password" problems will be deleted. Read the forum FAQ and follow the instructions there - that's what we have one for...
-
Returning Visitors
If you are a returning visitor who never received your confirmation email, then odds are your email provider is blockinig emails from our server. The only thing that can be done to get around this is you will have to try creating another forum account using an email address from another domain.
If you are a returning visitor to the forum and can't log in using your old forum name and password but used to be able to then chances are your account is deleted. Purges of the databases are done regularly. You will have to create a new forum account and you should be all set.
Battery Charged, Starter Spins Slowly, No Start
- Thread starter cowboyup3371
- Start date
Starter is in the bike and I turned the engine with the button so it seems everything is working so far:clap:. It did seem a little weak but like I said, the crank is definitely moving (removed the ignition cover) so I'll wait and see what happens when I put gas to it. I have the carbs back on the bike but not totally connected so I'll try to do that much after lunch and before I go to work this afternoon.
G
Guest
Guest
Good deal, glad to hear it. It will probably run better after your brushes seat in with a little use. Hope you didn't use the brush holder I sent, one brush was frozen. I just sent it to show the position of the insulating bushings.
No, I used the "new" ones I bought but I'm wondering if maybe I should have bought another set as the one permanently attached seems to be grinding itself down again.
Thank you again OldVet
Thank you again OldVet
G
Guest
Guest
You should replace them with new ones if you can. They both should slide freely in the retainers. I'm sure the old commutator wasn't nice to them. The power brush on the holder I sent is in reasonable shape and worn in on that commutator, but I doubt you can just buy the brush that has the braid crimped and soldered to the plate. I understand with the history of bike that it came from that it was hardly used and low mileage before it became a behind the barn ornament.
Last edited:
S
sebby110
Guest
Cowboy;
I'm just getting to this thread and I needed to read all 7 pages (whew !!). But I liked the way plot unfolded
OldVet, you're a real champ in my book :clap:
If you decide to get to the bottom of the issue with your older core unit (if you haven't chucked it already), let me lend you my 2 cents from my very similar experience.
My bike was cranking over very slowly (frustrating as all heck), even when I was boosting it from my car battery. After some troubleshooting, my conclusion was it was the starter. I pulled it, opened it up and traced the problem to several broken strands of wire going to one of the brushes. There was still some wire connected, which is why I think it was still cranking, but it wasn't the full wire. It was really tight and awkward to get to it too. I bridged the bad wire, coated it, reassembled and she was kick'n like new (lot's of spin and torque). Worked fine ever since.
I'm gamblin there's a bad wire somewhere. My point is that it might look OK, but it might be somewhat fraid and not taking or giving full load.
Your mission "Cowboy", should you choose to accept it is , Find that bad wire and teach it a lesson
I'm just getting to this thread and I needed to read all 7 pages (whew !!). But I liked the way plot unfolded
OldVet, you're a real champ in my book :clap:
If you decide to get to the bottom of the issue with your older core unit (if you haven't chucked it already), let me lend you my 2 cents from my very similar experience.
My bike was cranking over very slowly (frustrating as all heck), even when I was boosting it from my car battery. After some troubleshooting, my conclusion was it was the starter. I pulled it, opened it up and traced the problem to several broken strands of wire going to one of the brushes. There was still some wire connected, which is why I think it was still cranking, but it wasn't the full wire. It was really tight and awkward to get to it too. I bridged the bad wire, coated it, reassembled and she was kick'n like new (lot's of spin and torque). Worked fine ever since.
I'm gamblin there's a bad wire somewhere. My point is that it might look OK, but it might be somewhat fraid and not taking or giving full load.
Your mission "Cowboy", should you choose to accept it is , Find that bad wire and teach it a lesson
Not gonna happen
Not gonna happen
Like I said yesterday, something about the way that starter turned once I put it in seemed weak. Well, today, I put my temp tank on and tried to start it - nope
. It's turning very weakly and doesn't give any momentum to actually start. I know I saw the crank turn yesterday so I'm sure something is working but it's just not enough.
I'm done for awhile. I think I'm just going to plan on removing the engine early next year to replace the base gasket, repaint the frame, and do some other clean up stuff. I'll probably look into getting a new starter as well and see about other stuff that will need to be done that I have noticed this year. I do need to change the oil anyway so maybe I'll take that time to also pull the stator cover and make sure everything is engaging the way it should. But to do even that I need money for parts. If I'm going to get my family here and try to get some bills paid off then I have to wait on the bike.
I really do appreciate the help but I'm so depressed about this whole situation and how much riding time I've lost that I just need to walk away from it
Thank you again Oldvet for sending that to me. Like I said, I'll find a way to repay you.
Not gonna happen
Like I said yesterday, something about the way that starter turned once I put it in seemed weak. Well, today, I put my temp tank on and tried to start it - nope
. It's turning very weakly and doesn't give any momentum to actually start. I know I saw the crank turn yesterday so I'm sure something is working but it's just not enough.I'm done for awhile. I think I'm just going to plan on removing the engine early next year to replace the base gasket, repaint the frame, and do some other clean up stuff. I'll probably look into getting a new starter as well and see about other stuff that will need to be done that I have noticed this year. I do need to change the oil anyway so maybe I'll take that time to also pull the stator cover and make sure everything is engaging the way it should. But to do even that I need money for parts. If I'm going to get my family here and try to get some bills paid off then I have to wait on the bike.
I really do appreciate the help but I'm so depressed about this whole situation and how much riding time I've lost that I just need to walk away from it
Thank you again Oldvet for sending that to me. Like I said, I'll find a way to repay you.
G
Guest
Guest
Sorry to hear that. I'll keep my eye out for a starter deal. I drove my car for the first time in months yesterday to go pick up my new Shinko tires. I'll take the bike and 40MPG any day, against the RX8 and 20MPG high test. Before you try it again, I would check all wiring and cables for possible hidden damage at the terminals. I have seen cables hanging from a couple of strands hidden by the terminal, that still looks good from the outside, and hidden corrosion that can heat up and have the connection smoking.
Last edited:
Thank you OldVet. I'm glad you brought up the point about the cables themselves. I'd thought that I should replace them anyway but hadn't seen a reason to. I was getting 12v through them and there's no resistance that my meter picked up, assuming I tested it correctly. I don't have a DC Current meter but that's fine. If I did replace them just for the sake of ruling that out, do I need to go OEM or can I get similar sized cables at OReillys/Autozone/Napa?
G
Guest
Guest
Any good cable would do as long is the same gauge or larger. Finer strands resist vibration on a motorcycle better. I wouldn't just start replacing stuff, those issues would result in heat that you can test with your finger, physical inspection, removal and cleaning.
K
Killer2600
Guest
Just jumping into this thread and may not have all the details but has the engine to battery ground been checked?
You can do voltage drop tests with any multi-meter, I'd suggest doing that. To do so hook up the multi-meter at any section of cable/wiring (the battery positive terminal and the battery positive post on the starter for example), load/energize the circuit (crank the starter in my example) and measure the voltage. Ideally you'd like to lose nothing (no voltage loss/drop) in just the wiring so the meter would read 0.00 but in reality loss happens, the less the better (less than 0.5v on the positive side of the starter to battery connection, less than 0.2v on any ground side are the limit of what is generally acceptable).
Hope that's not too confusing and helps. To clarify the hook-up is similar to what you'd do to measure resistance in a wire/cable, the only difference is your meter is on DC volts, the wire/cable is hooked/wired up, and you run power through it as it would be in normal operation.
Hey Killer, thanks for the info. I have done the tests from the positive side but not on the ground. On the positive side, I am seeing a 1v difference between the battery side of the solenoid to the starter side. As the starter is now very very slowly turning, I'm told my ground itself should be good. I also tested tonight using jumper cables from the Jeep (NOT RUNNING) to the ground and positive cables on the bike. I did this to rule out a problem with the bike battery but achieved the same results.
GS Scott graciously informed me yesterday he had a spare starter for my bike he would send out tomorrow. I should get it about the time I return from Colorado (1 Aug) so I'll test it some more then.
GS Scott graciously informed me yesterday he had a spare starter for my bike he would send out tomorrow. I should get it about the time I return from Colorado (1 Aug) so I'll test it some more then.
G
Guest
Guest
One of the first things I did to my bike was to run a #4 AWG ground from battery negative to the motor. This will insure the starter has a good ground, SS star washers on both sides of the terminals.
K
Killer2600
Guest
That makes a good battery to battery connection but it still doesn't rule out positive or ground/negative wiring to the starter. Corroded or bad wires/connections will give the appearance of a weak/slow starter as the corrosion or bad section/connection resists the flow of current.
I'm thinking this goes back to what I asked earlier about replacing my cables. When I get the family out here I'll try replacing the battery to solenoid/fuse block, solenoid to starter, and ground to case cables just for a test. I will talk with OReillys tomorrow though to make sure what size I'll need.
Course, another test would be to just connect my bike battery directly to the starter while in the engine and see if that changes (much like the test when out of the bike. Right?
G
Guest
Guest
Hopefully the new starter is good and will make your troubleshooting a lot easier. New heavier cables would be cheap insurance. I started with a star washer sandwich with an old lawnmower that would start smoking at the starter motor terminal. could never seem to get it clean enough or tight enough. Put star washers on both sides of the terminal with a flat washer on the nut side, and never saw it smoke again. I use that, stainless steel nuts and bolts and lock nuts, and have yet to have any grounding or connection issues with the heavier wires. Other connections can be a problem. I just did the coil relay mod, because after three years of continuous riding, I noticed some problems with things that had already been cleaned or replaced. It made a huge difference, so I guess it's time to go through everything again. This time. I'll start with a Eastern Beaver fuse box, more relays, horns, headlight, winter heated gear, modern sealed connectors,etc.
K
Killer2600
Guest
Yes that test could be done to eliminate the wiring on the bike, just hook up both a power and ground to the starter and be careful not to short your battery leads together or to ground. If the starter still turns slow the problem would be limited to the starter or an engine that is difficult to turn over.
As for O'Reily's, if anyone in there knows bikes intimately I'd be surprised. Stock battery to starter and back wiring is 8 gauge I've been told on here, 8 or 10 is my guess without comparing whats on the bike to a piece of either. I know it's not 6, 4, or anything large like that.
That was my first thought when reading of the problem.
As I read it, the starter seems OK, and voltage is great, but it cannot turn the engine.
This suggests insufficient amperage, and that is a first sign of poor grounding. I recall buying a brand newcar and having starting problems similar to this. The problem turned out to be dirt between the cable and the engine block. Once cleaned and tightened, the problems disappeared.
GS bikes are notorious for having grounding problems, so on my GS bikes, I added a second ground cable from the battery to the frame, using 6AWG automotive cable .
FYI....for starter parts, or complete starters, you can check stockers.com. They sell individual brushes and sets already mounted on plates. Their pricing is good and their stuff is good quality.
Here is a link for GS550
http://stockers.com/index.php?oc=1
Went back and tested the cables again - I'm only getting a .2v loss between the battery and starter and nothing on the ground side so it looks like my cables are good. Should be seeing starter number 3 tomorrow but have to get ready to leave Friday so probably won't be able to install it until next weekend so we'll see.
The starter from GS Scott finally arrived this past Monday (I arrived back in town Tuesday) and the girls and I tried to swap it out yesterday. However, we found the battery to be totally drained because I'd left the key on after testing things last week
. Fortunately, the Motobatt fought back hard and today we had a great charge on it (13.2v 30 minutes after removing it from the charger) so off came the carbs and airbox. We then quickly tested the new starter, definitely torque in it now, and installed it. Before adding fuel, we tested the starter again in the bike and sure enough everything moved the way it was supposed to.After a short break to get back into the air conditioning, the eldest and I connected the test tank and soaked up the lovely noise of Suzuki power emanating from both mufflers:clap:. Testing with the multimeter showed ~13v at idle and 14.5 - 14.8 at 4500 RPM. Then, a quick chicken and potatoes dinner led to a short 40 mile ride with the family following in the truck. It sure feels good being back on the bike and I hope it will stay running for quite awhile longer.
I think the best thing for today is that both girls came out to help. I tried to ensure both ladies did quite a bit of wrenching and explained what little I understand about how the electrics and tools work. I don't know about them but I sure loved the time.
