I don't think it's exactly on the level to state categorically that the Gen 1 FJR is lemon-like. It's not. As I said, I have friends who have ridden them, and the one who put 70K on one did it on an '03-and that bike is still running very well (we still see the bike at bike nights). Neither of the guys I know who have them have had a single hiccup or reliability issue. In 2011, Cycle World listed the Gen 1 FJR as a number one used bike buy.
I was strongly advised to not look for them due to vibration issues, possible vale seal and head gasket failure issues that were completely knocked out from the release of the Gen 2. I know an acquaintance that has over 100k on his gen 1 FJR and still rides it almost everyday, no issues and love his bike. I also met a gentleman on the road that had a gen 1 FJR that blew it's head gasket at 110K miles and left him stranded thousands of miles from home, however he loved the bike and bought a Gen 2 FJR which he was riding. He said the gen 2 was a better bike then his gen 1. Your right Pilot it's a good machine and it's not a lemon. I guess the point I'm pressing is the Gen 2 is the better machine, refined and it's been fixed from all the gen 1 short comings. It was that gentleman I met on the road (Deal's gap exactly) that put the ST seed in my head for I was really not happy with the B-king for my trip. That's why when I first started looking for ST's I was focused mainly on a Gen 2 FJR.
Really personal preference.

